Anonymous asked: I'm sure you must get a lot of comments from people about being skinny. Do you have any advice for handling people's comments from "Oh my gosh I wish I could be like you I hate my body" to "Go eat something" ? This is something I've always struggled dealing with.
I’d actually be REALLY shocked if someone told me to “go eat something”. Maybe it’s just because I’m around a ton of feminist-y, body-positive folks, but I can’t imagine anyone telling me that in a non-joking manner and getting away with it.
To be honest, I don’t get many body-shamey comments related to my weight these days. I used to when I was heavier, though. The funny thing is, insults about my appearance were something I gradually became indifferent toward over time (especially since trolls on the web are only so compelling), but it’s the compliments I could never quite get used to. It generally makes me uncomfortable when anyone beyond a close friend comments on my body, especially in person. (I don’t feel compelled to respond to Internet commenters, but in real life, I have to come up with SOMETHING nice to say back, and I always feel so awkward.) When I lost a bunch of weight back in 2008/09, this would happen to frequently, and even though I’m sure these were well-meaning acquaintances who only meant to flatter, the whole thing just always made me feel super self-conscious. And here’s the thing: I’m totally cool with chatting about my clothes or my shoes or make-up, but it’s my body itself that I don’t like to discuss.
The following might seem contradictory to those who haven’t dealt with body issues, but here’s my theory on my hang-up. I’ve actively worked toward becoming more comfortable with my body over the years. Most of my close friends have seen me naked at one point or another. I shun pants at home and have no problem changing in front of my gay, male bestie or showering with my female one. I shunned exercise for many years because going to the gym made me feel worse about my body, not better, and I try to be conscious of whether I’m exercising for the “right” motivations (i.e. not guilt and self-hatred). But despite identifying very strongly with feminist views, I do care a lot about how I look and spend time on cultivating a personal “style”, whateverthefuck that means. Simultaneously, however, I dislike it when my appearance is pointed out to me. Unless it comes from a close friend, it feels like some sort of intrusion on my personal space, even if said with good intentions. I’m sure that part of my reaction is almost certainly related to having my body quite literally exposed and scrutinized by the masses. It makes me feel like a spectacle.
I think my discomfort also results from my suspicion that my body is being used as someone else’s yardstick. I know all too well what that’s like; when I was younger, I’d compare myself to other girls and throw up because I didn’t feel skinny enough next to them. I’d compliment my friends — and mean every word, but I’d do so while beating myself up at the same time. I get a lot of questions from readers who want to know what kind of exercises I do or how they, too, can eat what I eat without gaining weight. And alongside their queries are expressions of dissatisfaction with their own bodies. I don’t want to just ignore the topic altogether, but I never know how to respond. Because isn’t the underlying question — no matter how it’s phrased — always, “How can I be skinny like you?” It’s the “like you” part that really gets to me, because I don’t want to represent an ideal for anyone. I don’t even think skinniness itself is an ideal worth agonizing over.
I guess could answer these questions anyway, complete with a handy little disclaimer that says that being healthy should be the ultimate goal, NOT being skinny. The problem is that I don’t actually think that’s a compelling argument to someone who doesn’t like their body as it is. I know exactly what they’re thinking and how they’ll gloss over my concerns. I know these girls, because I used to be one of them, and sometimes, I wonder if I still am. It’s a huge Catch-22, and I don’t know any better than you do if there’s an appropriate response. If anyone has one, I’m all ears.
More burning questions? Ask Lena.
Related posts on body image, dieting, and health:
What Sex Blogging & The Freshman 15 Taught Me
The Gym-A-Phobe’s Guide To Having Your Cupcake & Eating It Too
Reader Question: “How do you reconcile your feminism and beauty/fashion consumption?”
Reader Question: “What are the merits of having small breasts?”
The Blueprint Myth
Sex And The Ivy: The Purge of Purging
Throughout October, I’m competing to win my own web series on SHAPE.com. I’d really appreciate it if you supported TheChicktionary.com in the Best Blogger Awards. (It’s super easy to vote, just a click!)
Following up on my post about the recent Twitter campaigns to bring awareness to 




